Individual review
Perspective card
Participant code
Initial score and rationale:
Veto condition:
Evidence request:
Group disagreement matrix
| Question | Technical | Commercial | Financial | Operational |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Initial gate | ||||
| Veto | ||||
| Missing evidence |
Material disagreement to preserve:
Final gate record
Decision owner:
Gate status:
□ COMMIT
□ TEST
□ HOLD
□ STOP
Rationale and minority view:
Reopening condition:
Operator Collective Test
- Which human operator performed the critical work?
- Which tasks could agentic systems accelerate?
- Which decision must remain human?
- What evidence would prove that this intervention created value?
May the Independent Reviewer also operate the system? What information should each seat receive?
Amend the default collective
| KEEP | CHANGE | KILL | TEST |
|---|---|---|---|